Grandma LucysOrganic Pumpkin

Vitamin B3. Dogs can make some from the amino acid tryptophan; cats cannot make enough and must get it from food, which is one of many reasons cat food and dog food are not interchangeable. Water-soluble and safe at food levels. Expected on every complete food label.

An iron source. Iron carries oxygen in the blood, and meat supplies much of it, with the mineral supplement making up the rest. Ferrous sulfate is the inorganic form; iron proteinate or chelate is the same mineral bound to a protein fragment, which brands describe as more absorbable. Either is normal. Not an allergen.

Vitamin B1, essential for nerves and energy metabolism, and the vitamin most often behind cat food recalls. It is destroyed by heat and by some preservatives, so canned foods in particular must add it back. Cats are especially sensitive to running short. Its presence is expected; its absence from a cooked food would be a red flag.

Vitamin B2, used to turn food into energy. Present in meat and dairy but partly lost in cooking, so manufacturers top it up. Water-soluble and safe at the levels used in food. Its presence tells you the food was formulated to a complete nutrient profile, not that anything unusual is going on.

Vitamin B9, needed for cell division and healthy blood. Standard fortification in complete foods for dogs and cats. Water-soluble, no toxicity concern at food levels. Its main relevance to a shopper is none: it is there because the recipe was balanced properly.